Bob, usually I agree with you, but I'm not with you on this one. There were guys here ( mostly developers or website owners) who successfully sold a domain, because they didn't really used it and after that, they started looking info about how to sell, promote, transfer, do escrow and others, at this point, you can't name them a 'domainer'. Also, there were beginners who successfully sold a domain for xxxx(some even low xxxxx), but they could not replicate that sale months/years after the first sale and even the one's who sold some, they could not make a profit at the end of the year. For me, to be a successful domainer, you need some constant sales(or at least inquiries) over the course of one year and you need to have at least $1 more than you have spent on a particular year(including acquisition, renewals and in some instances an average hourly rate, to compensate your time spent).