It doesn't matter. If people play the lottery, a few people will "succeed" even though their actions are not worthy of the good fortune that comes after they get lucky.
Domainers don't even know simple math. If I have a name that can fetch zero on the forums, but has a one in a thousand chance of getting a sale for 3K, then the value of that name is $3,000 divided by 1,000, which makes it a $3 name. That is assuming that you will either get 3K or zero.
Most people have absolute garbage that stands a one in a hundred chance of selling for a few hundred or so. If the name doesn't sell for a few hundred, then the name likely never sells. Those names are worth zero, even if one out of two hundred of the garbage names sells for $200 once in a while. You either get that concept or not. Probably 95 percent of people on forums have no idea how to factor in the odds of getting the sale, and they never account for the time spent in trying to get it.
To explain it better, imagine you are on a flight and your favorite celebrity sex symbol is on the flight. What are the odds that YOU are going to get a date? Well, in the domainers world, the value of that proposition is 100 percent, because they can give an example of some nobody at some point in history getting a date with a movie star or celebrity. Domainers take the best case scenario and then claim that is the value. They really have no understanding of what the hell they are talking about, and they are terrible businessmen and women as a whole, because great business people know that a good business is one in which you offer a product or service that you yourself would buy at that price. Domainers are offering dog shit that they would never buy for any price, and they expect people to pay their rent by offering up their loser names.
And that is why they will never be taken seriously as a group. You hardly ever hear a story of someone bragging about what a great deal they gave someone. They are always bragging about the brutal deal that they suckered someone into.