@michaeljkrell, it would be nice if you could answer some questions:
1) Do you really think, that the seller has to pay $100 for these designs?
2) Do you really think, that the buyer will pay $2000-$3000 seeing these?
1) No, why should you pay $100 for bold text? You can't tell them apart.
2) A buyer may pay $2000 - $3000 for the domain name, but they'd be foolish to retain the logo.
These are all very nice logos and nicer than what an enduser would end up getting spending a $100-$200 at a site like 99 designs. They are bold, easy to read, and general enough to work for a variety of different companies.
What about them isn't quality to you?
Is there anything
unique about these logos? Does it not look like the same font to you? As a seller, when we see 5+ domains published at once and we can't tell them apart, this is a problem. It's like the designer has a default bold font, add's some vector colors for an image, then repeats this process for every logo they do.
Furthermore, to go as far and say these are better designs than something you'd pay $100 - $200 from 99Designs.com is a blatant lie. I can understand you wanting to stand behind your company's work, but to go as far as degrading another company is beneath BrandBucket. Rather than making excuses, please focus on the quality issue at hand. Your sellers are losing faith in your designers. Improvise, adapt, and overcome, or you will no longer be
THE brandable marketplace. - I say that out of love.
Logo's from 99 Designs.com
Logos from BrandRoot.com
Logos from Namerific.com
I scraped the logo's from domains that BrandBucket sold this month, and it'd be far fetched to say the logos
@Simdes provided is what your customers buy. There are a few low quality logo's mixed in the sales, but for the most part the common factor to your sales is a quality logo. It's almost like you're allowing these poor logo's on your marketplace just to make the other domains look good. Please
@michaeljkrell take this constructively. I have a BrandBucket portfolio with premium logo's. I sell off the domains with bad logo's and lately, I've been noticing the domains I resell as BrandBucket accept are published with embarrassing logo's. I say this because there is obviously an issue with quality control.
In consideration of other sellers, I won't paste the scraped logo's publicly on this forum. I'll post the logo's of my last 2 sales.
I thank BrandBucket for creating these unique logo's that helped sell my domains.
R/e/p/i/q is still using the logo BrandBucket provided. Proving a good logo adds value to the domain purchase. These logo's are obviously more unique than the logo's
@Simdes screenshot. How can you do him a disservice with poor logo's, then tell him there's nothing wrong with the quality??
P.S. Is possible to change/replace with different/my own logos?
Anyway, thank you for answer, Michael...
Obviously, I'm grilled about this whole issue. How do we move forward when I can't trust BrandBucket's logo designers to consistently provide quality logo's? Based on what other members have said, I think the best option to sell on BrandBucket is to have our own logo designer so we can approve the quality. Obviously, BrandBucket and I have different views on the definition of logo quality.
I have some friends who are graphic designers. I mentioned I have hundreds of brandable domains that need designs. They are excited because this job is more than $5 each per logo. I mean if that's all the incentive to be a designer, why not spend 5 minutes doing a low quality logo and knock out 12 per hour thus yielding $60 an hour! My friends being students, are building their design portfolio. Anytime they can publish a live logo design, it adds to their portfolio. Furthermore the incentive to providing a quality logo is beyond monetary. Simply put, when a domain sells, and the buyer decides to retain the logo, they now have a stronger portfolio as they can say they did the logo for X company.
How can I begin submitting logo's? Will the amount I pay for logo be discounted in the listing fee? ie $5 listing fee's and no logo design award if I submit my own logos?