Thanks. This would make sense from my review of organic ranking. Can I list on squadhelp as well as on brandbucket? Why did you choose squadhelp?
I think you are not allowed to list your domains on both sites.
4 years ago I was on Brandbucket, lots of domains (I owned around 0.5% of total inventory back in 2016), no sales, so I sold all my names (70+) to domainers (ROI was good).
Then I switched to Brandpa, again lots of domains (I owned around 3% of total inventory when Brandpa was new), and I managed to sold 3 names within one year - and then absolutely no sale there for 2 years, so once again, I sold all my names (60+) on Brandpa to domainers (ROI was great).
Then I chose SH because it was the newest brandable marketplace with a moderate size of inventory, with lots of features the other marketplaces lacked, and it seemed they were spending a lot on advertising. There were no fees 1.5 years ago, this was also a huge plus. The commission was (and is still) large, but that was not an issue for me. I managed to sell 2 domains out of around 30 in the last 12 months.
In addition to using SH, I add all my rejected and ineligible domains to Dan.com and Afternic, and I have a very nice STR. Most of my domains on Dan are .co, and I have a handful of .com, .eu and .xyz names. I sold one name for $1500, one for $1000, and I had a couple of sales for $3-500, and lots of sales around $200.
What is your annual STR if you mind sharing ? I have 1.45% annual STR and no sale from 7 months with around 245 listings ... Are you sarisfied with results on SH ?
It's hard to tell as the number of domains are constantly growing. As I mentioned above, I sold 2 domains out of 30-ish since last October, so my STR is around 6-7% on SH, or even better. I'm pleased with the results. I'm still waiting for a sale related to a SH-owned name (currently I have ~10 such names on SH) - if I sold one such name, I would focus more on such domains.